Skip to content
WorldBrand.AI
HomeAboutBrand WikiAEOWorld ModelComing SoonBlog
WorldBrand.AI

The intelligence platform for brands in the AI era.

Products
  • AEO Intelligence
  • Brand Wiki
  • World Model
  • Enterprise
Company
  • About
  • Blog
  • Pricing
Brand Wiki
  • About Brand Wiki
  • Methodology
  • Sources
  • Editorial policy
  • API

© 2026 WorldBrand.ai. All rights reserved.

Privacy PolicyTerms of Use

Brand Wiki/Communication Services/Goodreads

Goodreads

Corporate brand

Unclaimed

A social reading platform where people catalog, rate, review, discuss, and discover books.

On this pageControversies↘History↘

Last updated October 14, 2026

Contents

  1. 1. Overview
  2. 2. History
  3. 3. Products and positioning
  4. 4. Controversies
  5. 5. Marketing campaigns
  6. 6. Brand decisions
  7. 7. Recent events
  8. 8. Related entries
  9. 9. Sources

Company facts

Goodreads

Industry
Communication Services · Digital Reading & Literature
Headquarters
San Francisco, California, United States
Founded
2006
Founder
Otis Chandler and Elizabeth Khuri Chandler
Parent
Amazon.com, Inc.
Website
www.goodreads.com
Country
United States
Owner
Amazon.com, Inc.
Group
Amazon
On this page9
  1. 1. Overview
  2. 2. History
  3. 3. Products and positioning
  4. 4. Controversies
  5. 5. Marketing campaigns
  6. 6. Brand decisions
  7. 7. Recent events
  8. 8. Related entries
  9. 9. Sources

Overview

Goodreads is an American social cataloging and reading-discovery platform operated by Goodreads, Inc., an Amazon subsidiary. Its central purpose is to help readers organize their personal libraries while discovering books through ratings, written reviews, recommendations, quotations, author information, and community discussion. Unlike a conventional online bookstore, Goodreads is organized around the reader’s ongoing relationship with books: users can mark titles as read, currently reading, or want to read; create custom shelves; record progress; rate books on a five-star scale; publish reviews; follow friends and authors; and participate in groups, polls, surveys, blogs, and discussion boards. The service was founded in December 2006 by Otis Chandler and Elizabeth Khuri Chandler and launched publicly in January 2007. The founding concept emerged when Otis Chandler was looking through a friend’s bookshelf and wanted to recreate the experience of browsing someone else’s collection while adding a way to see what that person thought about each book. Goodreads therefore addressed a problem that became increasingly important as book purchasing and reading moved online: discoverability. Its community-generated data gave readers a way to find books through the preferences and judgments of other readers rather than relying only on retailer search results or professional editorial recommendations. In its early period, Goodreads grew largely through personal referrals and word of mouth. The founders initially operated the service with a very small user base and without formal institutional funding. By December 2007, the platform reported approximately 650,000 members and about 10 million books added to its catalog. Angel investment and later venture funding supported product development and expansion. In 2010, Goodreads opened an application programming interface that allowed outside developers to access portions of its book and rating data. In 2011, it acquired Discovereads, a recommendation service using behavioral and similarity-based analysis to suggest books. Goodreads subsequently introduced algorithmic recommendations tied to users’ ratings and reading activity. The platform expanded rapidly during the early 2010s. By July 2012, it reported 10 million members, 20 million monthly visits, and approximately 30 employees. In late 2012, it reported more than 11 million members, hundreds of millions of cataloged books, and tens of thousands of user-created book clubs. Amazon announced an agreement to acquire Goodreads on March 28, 2013, at a time when Goodreads had more than 16 million readers. The acquisition placed one of the largest online reader communities inside the company that already dominated digital bookselling and operated Kindle. Goodreads remained a distinct consumer service, but the transaction connected it more closely to Amazon’s book ecosystem. Amazon later retired Shelfari, its other social book-cataloging property, and directed users toward Goodreads. Goodreads’ major consumer features include personal bookshelves, reading challenges, annual reading summaries, book previews, quotations, trivia, giveaways, author interviews, author blogs, and the Goodreads Choice Awards. The annual reading challenge encourages members to set a target number of books and track progress throughout the year. The My Year in Books feature gives users a retrospective view of their reading, including books completed, pages read, average ratings, and other activity statistics. The Goodreads Choice Awards, launched in 2009, use member voting to select popular books across multiple categories and have become a highly visible reader-driven awards program. The company’s catalog depends on a combination of publisher, wholesaler, library, retailer, and community-supplied information. Volunteer Goodreads librarians help correct book and author records, add editions, and improve cover and metadata quality. This collaborative cataloging model…

History

Goodreads originated with a simple physical-world observation: a bookshelf can reveal a person’s interests and provide an immediate source of recommendations. Otis Chandler developed the idea after browsing a friend’s books and imagining a digital service where people could display their collections and explain what they thought of the books they had read. Chandler, who had a programming background, founded the company with Elizabeth Khuri Chandler, a journalist and writer whom he had met while both were studying at Stanford. The service was incorporated in 2006 and launched in January 2007. The founders initially built Goodreads through personal networks and word of mouth. Its early appeal came from combining several functions that had previously been scattered across library catalogs, blogs, online forums, retailer pages, and personal spreadsheets. Members could search for books, create shelves, rate titles, write reviews, follow friends, and compare reading tastes. The platform’s community model made the catalog more useful over time because members added editions, corrected information, supplied cover images, and contributed reviews and recommendations. Goodreads’ early growth was notable for a company that began with limited resources. During its first year, the founders operated without formal institutional financing. By December 2007, Goodreads reported approximately 650,000 members and 10 million books added to the site. Angel funding of roughly $750,000 was reported that year, followed by a $2 million investment from True Ventures in 2009. These funds supported engineering, infrastructure, and the development of features that made Goodreads more than a static catalog. In October 2010, Goodreads opened an application programming interface, enabling external developers to use selected book, author, and rating data. In 2011, the company acquired Discovereads, a recommendation engine that used machine-learning techniques to infer which books a user might enjoy from prior ratings and from the behavior of readers with similar tastes. Goodreads subsequently introduced recommendation algorithms based on the ratings members supplied. The company’s founders argued that direct reader ratings could offer a more relevant signal than retailer behavior, which might include browsing, gifts, or purchases made for someone else. The platform expanded quickly during 2011 and 2012. Goodreads passed five million members in 2011 and reported 10 million members, 20 million monthly visits, and approximately 30 employees by July 2012. Later in 2012, it announced more than 11 million members, roughly 395 million cataloged books, and more than 20,000 user-created book clubs. Membership remained free, although registration was required for most interactive functions. Users increasingly treated Goodreads as a personal reading record, a recommendation source, an online social network, and a place to interact with authors. The company also became increasingly important to the publishing industry. Authors could maintain profiles, write blogs, conduct interviews, offer giveaways, and communicate with readers. Goodreads promoted tools intended to help authors reach relevant audiences, and thousands of writers used the service for visibility and reader engagement. At the same time, the prominence of Goodreads ratings created tension. A rating could influence a book’s public reputation before publication, and disputes sometimes arose when authors encouraged supporters to respond to negative reviews or when readers used reviews to comment on an author’s public behavior. A major operational change came in January 2012, when Goodreads shifted its primary book-metadata sourcing away from Amazon’s public Product Advertising API. The company cited the restrictions associated with Amazon’s interface and sought a more flexible combination of data from Ingram, the Library of Congress, WorldCat, publishers, and community contributors. Goodreads attempted to reassure users that their shelves and reading histories would not be lost. After Amazon acquired Goodreads, Amazon data again became part of the platform’s metadata sources. On March 28, 2013, Amazon announced an agreement to acquire Goodreads. The deal was completed during the second quarter of that year for an undisclosed amount in the contemporary public announcement. At the time, Goodreads had more than 16 million members, and the acquisition was widely viewed as strategically important because Goodreads had become a leading independent destination for book discovery and reviews. Amazon had already acquired Shelfari, another social book-cataloging service, in 2008. The Goodreads transaction therefore consolidated Amazon’s presence across online bookselling, e-reading, and social reading. Goodreads’ founders said the management team would remain involved and that the reviewing process would be protected, while critics feared that Amazon’s control of multiple layers of the book market could reduce competition and increase its influence over which authors and titles received exposure. After the acquisition, Goodreads continued to operate as a distinct brand. Its membership reached approximately 20 million by July 2013. The service maintained its community features while becoming more closely connected to Amazon’s broader book ecosystem, including Kindle-related integration and links to purchase books. In 2016, Amazon announced that Shelfari would be retired and that users would be offered tools to export or migrate their information to Goodreads. That decision further established Goodreads as Amazon’s principal social reading platform. Goodreads’ signature programs developed during this period. The Goodreads Choice Awards, first introduced in 2009, allowed members to vote for books across multiple categories and became one of the most prominent reader-voted awards programs in publishing. The annual Reading Challenge encouraged participants to set reading goals and document their progress. My Year in Books, developed as a recurring annual retrospective, summarized each member’s reading activity through measures such as books completed, pages read, average book length, and average rating. These features reinforced Goodreads’ role as both a community and a personal data archive. The platform’s catalog was supported by volunteer Goodreads librarians, who helped maintain author and edition records and coordinated their work through Goodreads community groups. The catalog was valuable because it combined structured metadata with large quantities of user-created content, but the data remained proprietary. In December 2020, Goodreads stopped issuing new API keys and deactivated older keys that had not been used recently. Developers and third-party services consequently lost much of the official access they had previously enjoyed. Goodreads’ scale also exposed it to persistent criticism. Review bombing became a recurring problem, with books receiving large numbers of negative ratings from people who had not read them, sometimes before publication. Authors and commentators argued that manual moderation was too slow and that coordinated campaigns could amount to harassment or extortion. Goodreads published and revised policies addressing personal attacks, off-topic reviews, threats, and author-focused harassment, and it stated that it was developing methods to identify inauthentic activity. Critics nevertheless continued to question the consistency and speed of enforcement. In 2023, disputes involving apparently AI-generated counterfeit books listed under author Jane Friedman’s name drew attention to weaknesses in identity and catalog verification across Amazon and Goodreads. The same year, the Cait Corrain controversy demonstrated how fake accounts could allegedly be used to manipulate ratings against other authors. Broader reporting also criticized Goodreads for limited product development and an aging user experience, especially as newer services such as The StoryGraph offered competing approaches to reading tracking and recommendations. Despite these controversies, Goodreads remains active and globally influential. By September 2023, the service reported more than 150 million members. Its continuing importance comes from the combination of a large book database, a durable social graph, millions of reader reviews, personal reading histories, author-facing tools, and a strong position in the discovery stage of book consumption. Under Amazon ownership, Goodreads remains a major digital-reading brand whose influence extends beyond its own website into publishing publicity, reader culture, and the online economics of book visibility.

  • 2023

    Goodreads reports more than 150 million members

    [1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    The service is reported to have more than 150 million members by September 2023.

  • 2020

    Goodreads restricts API access

    [1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    The platform deactivates older API keys and states that new API keys will no longer be issued.

  • 2016

    Shelfari is retired in favor of Goodreads

    [1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    Amazon closes Shelfari and gives users options to export or migrate their reading data to Goodreads.

  • 2016

    User reviews exceed fifty million

    [1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    Goodreads announces that members have posted more than 50 million book reviews.

  • 2013

    Amazon announces acquisition

    [3]Goodreads joins the Amazon familygoodreads.com

    Amazon announces an agreement to acquire Goodreads, integrating the leading social book community into its broader books business.

  • 2013

    Goodreads membership reaches approximately twenty million

    [1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    Several months after the acquisition announcement, Goodreads reports that its user base has grown to approximately 20 million members.

  • 2012

    Metadata sourcing shifts away from Amazon’s public API

    [4]Goodreads transitions to new data sourcesgoodreads.com

    Goodreads begins using Ingram, library sources, publishers, and other providers to reduce dependence on Amazon’s public metadata interface.

  • 2012

    Membership exceeds ten million

    [1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    Goodreads reports more than 10 million members, 20 million monthly visits, and approximately 30 employees by July.

  • 2011

    Discovereads acquisition and algorithmic recommendations

    [1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    Goodreads acquires Discovereads and introduces recommendation features based on ratings and similarity among readers.

  • 2010

    API opens to outside developers

    [1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    Goodreads provides an API that allows developers to access selected book, author, and rating information.

Showing the 10 most recent.

Products and positioning

A large-scale, community-driven social reading and book-discovery platform positioned between a personal library manager, a review community, an author engagement channel, and a reader-oriented cultural database.

  • Social reading platform · 2007

    Goodreads website and mobile reading community

    The core Goodreads service lets members search a large catalog of books, build personal shelves, record reading status, rate titles from one to five stars, publish reviews, follow friends and authors, and participate in groups and discussions. The platform combines structured bibliographic records with user-generated commentary and social activity. It is primarily a discovery, tracking, and community product rather than a standalone book retailer, although many pages connect users to book-purchasing and digital-reading options in Amazon’s ecosystem.

  • Reading management · 2007

    Personal bookshelves

    Goodreads provides default shelves such as read, currently-reading, and to-read, while allowing users to create custom shelves for genres, themes, ownership status, rereads, or personal projects. Shelves form the foundation of the service’s social and recommendation systems because they make a member’s reading history visible, searchable, and comparable with those of other users.

  • User-generated content · 2007

    Book ratings and reviews

    Members can assign books a one-to-five-star rating and optionally add written reviews. These ratings and reviews are among Goodreads’ most influential assets, helping readers assess unfamiliar titles and giving publishers and authors a public measure of reader response. The same openness also creates moderation challenges, particularly when users rate books before reading them or coordinate negative campaigns.

  • Discovery and personalization · 2011

    Book recommendations

    Goodreads recommends books using information such as ratings, shelves, reading history, and the behavior of readers with similar tastes. The service strengthened this capability through its 2011 acquisition of Discovereads. Recommendations address the central discoverability problem of a large digital catalog, although critics have argued that the algorithm and interface have not advanced as quickly as competing reading platforms.

  • Reader-voted awards · 2009

    Goodreads Choice Awards

    The Goodreads Choice Awards are an annual program in which Goodreads members vote for books across multiple categories. The process generally begins with nominated or user-selected books and proceeds through successive voting rounds. Because the awards reflect a large reader community rather than a traditional expert jury, they function both as a cultural popularity signal and as a promotional event for authors and publishers.

  • Reading habit and progress tracking

    Reading Challenge

    The Reading Challenge allows users to set an annual target for the number of books they want to complete and track their progress during the year. Participants can display their goals, compare progress with friends, and update the challenge as they read. The feature turns personal reading into a measurable and shareable activity, reinforcing Goodreads’ community-oriented approach to reading management.

  • Annual reading report · 2014

    My Year in Books

    My Year in Books is a personalized annual summary of a member’s Goodreads activity. It can include the number of books read, pages completed, average book length, average ratings, and comparisons among titles in the user’s reading history. The feature encourages reflection and sharing while demonstrating the value of Goodreads’ long-term reading data.

  • Author services

    Author profiles and promotional tools

    Authors can create or claim profiles, connect their books to their identity, publish blog posts, participate in interviews and question-and-answer activities, offer giveaways, and reach readers through the platform’s discovery features. These tools make Goodreads an important promotional venue in publishing, but they also create boundaries that the service must enforce between legitimate author engagement, self-promotion, and attempts to influence reviews.

  • Content access

    Book previews and digital-reading integrations

    Goodreads pages may provide previews or listening samples through integrations with Kindle Cloud Reader, Audible, and related Amazon services. Kindle devices including the second-generation Paperwhite and Kindle Voyage also offered Goodreads-related social features. These integrations connect Goodreads’ discovery and community functions with Amazon’s e-reading and audiobook products.

Controversies

  • 2023

    Counterfeit AI-generated books listed under Jane Friedman’s name

    Jane Friedman reported that apparently AI-generated books had been listed using her name on Amazon and Goodreads. The dispute raised concerns about author identity verification, catalog integrity, and the speed of removal procedures.

    Source
  • 2023

    Cait Corrain fake-account review-bombing controversy

    Cait Corrain was accused of creating fake Goodreads accounts to post negative ratings against other authors. The episode contributed to renewed criticism of Goodreads’ vulnerability to coordinated manipulation and the consequences of prepublication ratings.

    Source
  • 2023

    Criticism of product stagnation and moderation

    Publishing observers and users criticized Goodreads for an aging interface, limited feature development, weak accessibility and moderation systems, and the risks created by its dominant position in online book reviews.

    Source
  • 2021

    Review bombing, harassment, and extortion allegations

    Authors and commentators reported coordinated low ratings, targeted harassment, and threats to flood books with negative reviews unless demands were met. Critics argued that manual moderation and enforcement were insufficient, especially for marginalized authors.

    Source
  • 2012

    Disputes over author self-promotion and review manipulation

    A controversy involving author encouragement to influence the visibility of a negative Goodreads review contributed to wider debate over author conduct, reader criticism, and the boundaries of acceptable participation on the platform.

    Source

Read more

Marketing campaigns

  • 2014My Year in Books

    Global

    Goodreads introduced an annual personalized reading recap that turns a member’s reading history into a set of statistics and shareable reflections.

    Outcome. The feature encouraged year-end engagement and made reading activity more visible as a personal and social identity signal.

    Source
  • 2009Goodreads Choice Awards

    Global

    Goodreads launched an annual reader-voted awards program that organizes popular books into genre and subject categories. The campaign uses community participation to generate attention for books and to reinforce Goodreads as a public measure of reader enthusiasm.

    Outcome. The awards became one of Goodreads’ most visible recurring programs and an important promotional event in the online publishing calendar.

    Source
  • Goodreads Reading Challenge

    Global

    The Reading Challenge invites members to set an annual book-count goal and track their progress publicly or privately throughout the year.

    Outcome. It became a recurring engagement mechanism that links reading habits, social accountability, and personal data tracking.

    Source

Brand decisions

  • 2020

    Restrict official API accessStrategy

    Background

    Goodreads maintained a proprietary catalog and user-data system while facing the operational and governance costs of supporting broad third-party access.

    Action taken

    The company deactivated API keys that had been inactive for more than 30 days and stated that it would not issue new keys.

    Aftermath

    Third-party developers and independent reading tools had fewer official options for integrating Goodreads data, increasing criticism about platform openness.

    • The StoryGraph — The reduction in Goodreads API access made alternative reading-tracking services more attractive to some developers and users, although no formal competitor statement is established here.
    Source
  • 2016

    Retire Shelfari and migrate users to GoodreadsStrategy

    Background

    Amazon operated two social book-cataloging properties and sought to concentrate its resources and community activity in one service.

    Action taken

    Amazon shut down Shelfari and offered users tools to export or transfer their information to Goodreads.

    Aftermath

    Goodreads became Amazon’s principal social reading and book-cataloging platform.

    Source
  • 2013

    Join AmazonM&A

    Background

    Goodreads had become a large independent community for book discovery and reviews, while Amazon controlled major parts of online bookselling and digital reading.

    Action taken

    Amazon agreed to acquire Goodreads and operate it as a subsidiary while retaining the Goodreads brand and community.

    Aftermath

    The acquisition expanded Amazon’s influence over book discovery and connected Goodreads more closely to Kindle and Amazon’s book ecosystem. It also prompted concerns about vertical integration and the independence of Goodreads’ review system.

    • Shelfari — Amazon later consolidated its social book-cataloging strategy by retiring Shelfari and directing users toward Goodreads.
    Source
  • 2013

    Tighten review and community standardsOther

    Background

    Disputes involving threats, author-focused attacks, aggressive self-promotion, and readers’ responses created pressure for clearer review rules.

    Action taken

    Goodreads announced that reviews threatening authors or primarily discussing author behavior rather than the book could be deleted, and later guidelines addressed personal attacks and off-topic content.

    Aftermath

    The policy established a clearer distinction between criticism of a book and harassment of an author, but moderation practices continued to attract criticism.

    Source
  • 2012

    Change primary book-metadata sourcesStrategy

    Background

    Goodreads considered Amazon’s public Product Advertising API too restrictive for the platform’s cataloging needs.

    Action taken

    The service shifted toward Ingram, the Library of Congress, WorldCat, publishers, and other metadata sources while planning to protect users’ shelves and reading histories.

    Aftermath

    The change temporarily reduced dependence on Amazon’s public data interface. After Amazon acquired Goodreads, Amazon data again became part of the service’s metadata ecosystem.

    Source
  • 2011

    Acquire Discovereads to strengthen recommendationsStrategy

    Background

    Goodreads sought to improve book discovery by using behavioral data and similarity analysis to identify titles that readers might enjoy.

    Action taken

    The company acquired Discovereads and incorporated recommendation technology into its service.

    Aftermath

    Goodreads introduced algorithmic recommendations based on user ratings and reading patterns, although later critics viewed the recommendation experience as relatively dated.

    Source

Recent events

  • 2020

    Goodreads stops issuing new API keys[1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    Regulation

    Goodreads deactivated API keys that had been inactive for more than 30 days and stated that it would no longer issue new API keys. The change reduced official programmatic access for developers and third-party reading tools.

  • 2016

    Amazon retires Shelfari in favor of Goodreads[1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    M&A

    Amazon announced that Shelfari would be shut down and that users could export or migrate their information to Goodreads. The move consolidated Amazon’s social book-cataloging properties around Goodreads.

  • 2016

    Goodreads announces more than 50 million user reviews[1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    Other

    Goodreads announced that its community had posted more than 50 million reviews, highlighting the scale of its user-generated book database.

  • 2013

    Amazon announces agreement to acquire Goodreads[3]Goodreads joins the Amazon familygoodreads.com

    M&A

    Amazon announced that it had agreed to acquire Goodreads, bringing the major social reading community into Amazon’s books business. The announcement generated mixed reactions because Goodreads was viewed as an important independent venue for book discovery and reviews.

  • 2013

    Goodreads reports rapid membership growth after Amazon deal[1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    M&A · Other

    Goodreads announced that its membership had reached approximately 20 million readers several months after Amazon disclosed the acquisition agreement.

  • 2012

    Goodreads changes its book-metadata sources[4]Goodreads transitions to new data sourcesgoodreads.com

    Other

    The platform moved away from Amazon’s public Product Advertising API and began relying more heavily on Ingram, the Library of Congress, WorldCat, publishers, and other sources. Goodreads said the change would provide greater flexibility and that user reading records would be protected.

  • 2012

    Goodreads revises review guidelines amid author-reader disputes[1]Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org

    Regulation · Other

    Following disputes involving author self-promotion, hostile reader behavior, and attempts to influence review visibility, Goodreads publicly clarified its review and community standards.

Related entries

  • Amazon
  • 365 by Whole Foods
  • 365 by Whole Foods Market
  • 365 Everyday Value
  • 365 Whole Food Market
  • 365 Whole Foods
  • 365 Whole Foods Market
  • AbeBooks
  • Alexa Internet
  • Amazon Air
  • Amazon Alexa
  • Amazon Appstore
  • Amazon Basics
  • Amazon Books
  • Amazon Business
  • Amazon Business MRO
  • Amazon Clinic
  • Amazon Elements
  • Amazon Essentials
  • Amazon Freight
  • Amazon Fresh
  • Amazon Go
  • Amazon Grocery
  • Amazon Lab126
  • Amazon Locker
  • Amazon Marketplace
  • Amazon MGM Studios
  • Amazon Music
  • Amazon Pay
  • Amazon Prime Air
  • Amazon Publishing
  • Amazon Robotics
  • Amazon Web Services
  • Amazon Web Services EMEA SARL, UK Branch
  • Annapurna Labs
  • Audible
  • AWS CloudFormation
  • Book Depository
  • Box Office Mojo
  • ComiXology

Sources9 sources

  1. 1Goodreadsen.wikipedia.org
  2. 2About Goodreadsgoodreads.com
  3. 3Goodreads joins the Amazon familygoodreads.com
  4. 4Goodreads transitions to new data sourcesgoodreads.com
  5. 5Growing Up Into Goodreadsgoodreads.com
  6. 6Goodreads privacy policygoodreads.com
  7. 7How Extortion Scams and Review Bombing Trolls Turned Goodreads Into Many Authors’ Worst Nightmaretime.com
  8. 8Goodreads, Amazon’s website for book lovers, causes problems in publishingwashingtonpost.com
  9. 9Cait Corrain review bombing controversyen.wikipedia.org

* Cite this profile: Cite the canonical profile. /brand-wiki/goodreads · Editorial policy · How profiles are compiled