Occupy Harvard was a student demonstration at Harvard University identifying itself with the global Occupy Movement. It sought to create a forum for discussing economic inequality at Harvard, in the United States, and throughout the world. It criticized Harvard's influence on global economic policy and its involvement with the American financial sector. It also supported wage campaigns by Harvard workers and a divestment demand initiated by Hotel Workers Rising.
Facing resistance from administration and police, the group established an encampment in Harvard Yard after a march on November 9, 2011. Immediately after this march, the gates to Harvard Yard were locked and only people with Harvard identity cards were allowed through. Although the encampment gained many faculty supporters, it was not popular among Harvard undergraduates. The security checkpoints were not removed until after the group packed up its tents in December 2011. Occupy Harvard continued to organize into 2012, with a focus on the university's library system.
The demonstration raised issues of privilege and economic inequality, particularly as they relate to students and administration at one of the world's wealthiest and best-known universities.[1] Supporters described Occupy Harvard as a "fight for Harvard's soul", questioning whether the university would "continue to prioritize money above social justice". Opponents called the demonstrators over-privileged and under-informed attention seekers.
Background
Harvard University is one of the most exclusive universities in the world, with an admission rate of 5.9%.[2] Harvard is famous for its wealthy graduates but also for its generous financial aid programs.[3] Its financial endowment of over $30 billion, on which it does not pay taxes, is the largest in the world.[4] It is one of the world's richest non-profits, competing only with the Catholic Church (and perhaps the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation).[5]
Many Harvard graduates work in the financial sector based on Wall Street; many others hold prominent positions in the world of business. Prominent faculty such as former president Larry Summers—who become director of the National Economic Council under Obama—have played major roles in shaping United States economic policy. This status has led critics to connect Harvard closely with America's domestic and international economic policies.[6]
Encampment
On November 9, 2011, hundreds of demonstrators (estimates range between 300 and 500; not all of them Harvard students) met at Harvard Law School and marched toward Harvard Yard.[5] After allowing through some students with identity cards, Harvard Police closed the gates on all of the protestors. Some reported police roughness and minor injuries.[20] Those who entered the Yard set up tents that had been stored previously in nearby dormitories, establishing a camp near the Yard's John Harvard statue.
The next morning (November 10), the group issued an official statement which included specific criticisms of Harvard management:[21]
"We see injustice in the 180:1 ratio between the compensation of Harvard’s highest-paid employee—the head of internal investments at Harvard Management Company—and the lowest-paid employee, an entry-level custodial worker. We see injustice in Harvard’s adoption of corporate efficiency measures such as job outsourcing. We see injustice in African land grabs that displace local farmers and devastate the environment. We see injustice in Harvard’s investment in private equity firms such as HEI Hotels and Resorts, which profits off the backbreaking labor of a non-union immigrant workforce. We see injustice in Harvard’s lack of financial transparency and its prevention of student and community voice in these investments." The group also announced that it would make policies through a regular
Positions
Finance recruiting
Occupy Harvard denounced finance industry, which it described as bad for the economy and a source of inequality. Campus opposition to corporate recruiting has increased, with some describing it as similar to military recruiting. Recent declines in recruitment rates for the finance sector have been attributed partly to the growing sense that these jobs are undesirable and unethical.[36]
On Monday, November 28, 2011, Occupy Harvard conducted a "Rally to Defend Freedom of Speech" in Harvard Yard. The group expressed solidarity with UC Berkeley and UC Davis, where students had recently come into conflict with police. About 25 of the demonstrators proceeded from the Yard to a Goldman Sachs recruiting session, behind held at Harvard's "On-Campus Interview Facility". They stood outside and chanted "Goldman Sachs, you can't hide / We can see your greedy side!" Students who attempted to enter were denied access to the building by Harvard Police and Office of Career Services officials, even after showing identity cards.[37][38]
Reception
Occupy Harvard received praise[62] and criticism[63][64] in The Harvard Crimson. The Crimson itself opposed the encampment and published numerous editorials urging the group to move out of Harvard Yard.[5][43][65] Contentious issues included the possible hypocrisy of privileged Harvard students, wastefulness of the tents, and, most of all, inconvenience created by the locked gates.[66] The Crimson also cited the possibility of anarchist violence.
See also
- Privately owned public space
- Educational privilege
- Legacy preferences
- Harvard Corporation
External links
Occupy Harvard
- Occupy Harvard website
- Occupy Harvard on Twitter
- "found footage: Occupy Harvard video of a pig discussing revolutionary strategy
- "Season's Greetings from Occupy Harvard" a short video in which "Occu-elves" deliver unpleasant gifts to "naughty" Harvard affiliates (including Larry Summers, Harvey Mansfield, and Niall Ferguson, and Robert Rubin).
- Video of students in Lamont Library arguing (unsuccessfully) with HUPD and unidentified men in suits about signs and the library free speech policy;
References
- Mary Carmichael and Billy Baker., "Occupy Harvard left up to students: Harvard officials decide to keep Harvard Yard locked in wake of Occupy tents", Boston Globe, November 11, 2011.^
- Blake Ellis, "Harvard, Princeton post record low acceptance rates", CNN Money, March 30, 2012.^
- Timothy Noah, "Does Harvard's 'affirmative action for the affluent' screw the proles?