Preliminary matches
The television special began with Io Shirai and Zoey Stark defending the NXT Women's Tag Team Championship against Toxic Attraction (Gigi Dolin and Jacy Jayne) and Indi Hartwell and Persia Pirotta in a Triple Threat Tag Team Scareway to Hell Ladder match. During the match, Pirotta tipped a ladder over, causing Stark to take out Dolin, Jayne, and Hartwell outside of the ring. Pirotta then prevented everyone else from retrieving the title belts, even powerbombing Dolin onto a ladder. Jayne touched one of the title belts, and countered a powerbomb from Pirotta into a hurricanrana into another ladder. Shirai pulled Jayne off a ladder onto another ladder and performed a Moonsault on Jayne onto it. After taking out Pirotta, Stark was on the receiving end of a Spinebuster onto a ladder by Hartwell. In the climax, as Shirai was at the top of a ladder, Hartwell tipped it over, causing Shirai to crash into another ladder outside the ring. Jayne distracted Hartwell enough for Dolin to get to the top of the ladder and push Hartwell off. Dolin then retrieved the belts to win the titles for Toxic Attraction for the first time.
Following this, Trick Williams and NXT North American Champion Carmelo Hayes pulled up to a haunted house, while Johnny Gargano and Dexter Lumis were in a security room. After Hayes and Williams mistaked a dead kid for Gargano, they entered the house.
Next, Grayson Waller, dressed as a vampire, introduced the audience to Halloween Havoc, only to be interrupted by Joe Gacy, who came for his match against Malik Blade. In the end, Harland appeared and grabbed Blade by the throat outside the ring, and back inside, Gacy performed a handspring clothesline to win the match.
In the third match, Diamond Mine issued an open challenge, which was accepted by Odyssey Jones, who chose to face NXT Cruiserweight Champion Roderick Strong in a non-title match. Jones dominated most of the match. In the end, The Creed Brothers (Brutus Creed and Julius Creed) distracted Jones, allowing Strong to perform a Jumping Knee to win the match.
Following this, a Halloween party took place backstage, where Xyon Quinn chokeslammed Robert Stone through a table.
In the fourth match, Raquel González defended the NXT Women's Championship against Mandy Rose in a Spin the Wheel, Make the Deal match. González entered the Performance Center on a motorcycle, and spun the wheel, which landed on "Chucky's Choice". Chucky chose a Trick or Street Fight. Outside the ring, Rose attacked González with a kendo stick, but González fought back and sent Rose into the plexiglass. Later, González attacked Rose with another kendo stick. Rose fought back and placed González onto a chair before using the kendo stick to trap her. González put on a hockey mask and used a fire extinguisher on Rose. González then sent Rose into the chairs set up on the top turnbuckle for a nearfall. González then set up the steel steps on the ring apron, but Rose tossed her into them for a nearfall. In the closing moments, González sent Rose through a table positioned in the corner for a nearfall. A hooded person then struck González with a shovel, allowing Rose to perform a Bicycle Knee on González to win the title for the first time, meaning that Toxic Attraction held all of the women's championships on the NXT brand. Afterwards, the hooded person was revealed to be Dakota Kai.
Following this, Carmelo Hayes and Trick Williams walked around the haunted house, where they punched a "monster" before being scared at creepy people. Andre Chase then appeared and led Hayes and Williams through the house. Afterwards, Johnny Gargano and Dexter Lumis left the security room and put the NXT Zombie in charge. Chase was then eaten by zombies. Later, Gargano and Lumis attacked Williams and Hayes, who fended off the zombies. They ran away when Gargano scared them. Gargano then said that next time, they're doing the party.
Afterwards, Grayson Waller continued to host the show until LA Knight, also dressed as a vampire, interrupted. Solo Sikoa then made his NXT debut, and caused Knight and Waller to retreat.
In the penultimate match, MSK (Wes Lee and Nash Carter) defended the NXT Tag Team Championship against Imperium (Fabian Aichner and Marcel Barthel) in a Spin the Wheel, Make the Deal match. A random child spun the wheel, which landed on "Lumberjack O'Lantern Match". Carter and Lee performed stereo dives on Aichner and Barthel. Aichner performed a rolling senton on Carter and Lee. Lee leapt over the ring post onto Aichner and the lumberjacks. Carter then sent himself and Aichner onto the lumberjacks. Afterwards, all of the lumberjacks were sent to the back. In the closing moments, Carter performed a Hot Fire Flame on Barthel for a nearfall. Barthel performed a running PK on Carter. Aichner performed a Brainbuster on Lee, and he and Barthel performed the European Bomb on Lee to win the titles.
