Preliminary matches
The television special began with Tony D'Angelo (accompanied by Channing "Stacks" Lorenzo) taking on Dijak to determine the number one contender for the NXT North American Championship. During the match, Lorenzo interfered in the match, only to be handcuffed to the ropes by Dijak. In the end, while D'Angelo was arguing with Lorenzo about taking the bullet for D'Angelo, Dijak performed a Cyclone Boot on D'Angelo to become the number one contender for the title.
Next, The Creed Brothers (Brutus Creed and Julius Creed) were scheduled to take on Indus Sher (Sanga and Veer Mahaan). However, Sanga revealed that Veer wasn't there and instead, Jinder Mahal made his return. Mahal and Sanga then attacked The Creed Brothers.
The second match was the gauntlet match to determine the number one contenders for the NXT Tag Team Championship. Pretty Deadly (Kit Wilson and Elton Prince) picked their first opponents as two enhancement talents, "The Rockers" (Jimmy Jackson and Brian Williams). Wilson and Prince eliminated The Rockers following Spilt Milk before Malik Blade and Edris Enofé entered next. As Blade attempted a pinning combination on Prince, Wilson reversed the pin to eliminated Enofé and Blade. Josh Briggs and Brooks Jensen were supposed to enter last, however, they were found beaten down, and a returning Gallus (Mark Coffey and Wolfgang) took their place. Gallus performed an Enziguri/Bodyslam combination on Prince, and Wolfgang pinned him to become the number one contenders for the NXT Tag Team Championship.
Following this, footage was shown of Carmelo Hayes and Trick Williams in Apollo Crews' cafe, and Hayes writing a diary about being himself. Hayes and Williams talked about taking Crews down before drinking coffee.
After that, the "Countdown to the New Year" vignette was revealed to be a returning Tiffany Stratton, who talked about her return.
In the third match, Bron Breakker defended the NXT Championship against Grayson Waller. During the match, Waller sent Breakker into the middle turnbuckle, which fell apart, causing the referees to repair the ring. In the climax, as Waller attempted his elbow drop, the middle rope snapped. Waller was unable to make it to the ring before the ten count, thus Breakker retained by countout.
Next, Apollo Crews watched Carmelo Hayes and Trick Williams' promo on a tablet when Axiom showed up. The two then agreed to team up to face Hayes and Williams the following week.
In the fourth match, Hank Walker (accompanied by Drew Gulak) took on Charlie Dempsey. In the end, Dempsey applied a bow and arrow submission hold on Walker. Dempsey rolled Walker to the center of the ring to force a submission and win the match.
Next, while Sol Ruca was practicing handstands backstage, she was confronted by Alba Fyre, setting up a match between the two for the following week.
In the penultimate match, Jinder Mahal (accompanied by Sanga) took on Julius Creed. In the climax, Sanga appeared and distracted Julius, allowing Mahal to avoid a Shooting Star Press. Mahal followed up with a Yakuza Kick and the Khallas to win the match.
Before the main event, Fallon Henley and Kiana James checked on Josh Briggs and Brooks Jensen backstage, and also mocked Gallus (Mark Coffey and Wolfgang). This would set up a match pitting Briggs and Jensen against Gallus for the following week.
Main event
The main event was the 20-woman Battle Royal to determine the number one contender for Roxanne Perez's NXT Women's Championship at NXT Vengeance Day. At the start of the match, Lyra Valkyria eliminated Cora Jade, followed by Kiana James eliminating Tatum Paxley and almost doing the same to Fallon Henley, only for James to prevent Henley from elimination. After Lash Legend eliminated Amari Miller, Sol Ruca walked on her hands to prevent elimination. Afterwards, Valentina Feroz was eliminated by Thea Hail. Indi Hartwell would then eliminate Legend, followed by Valkyria performing a Hurricanrana on James to eliminate her. Zoey Stark then tossed Dani Palmer onto Legend and James outside the ring to eliminate her. Jade then returned, only to be tossed over the top rope by Valkyria again. After Ivy Nile was eliminated, Toxic Attraction (Gigi Dolin and Jacy Jayne) eliminated Hartwell. Hail and Henley were eliminated followed by Nikkita Lyons performing a spin kick on Elektra Lopez to eliminate her. Wendy Choo prevented elimination with a pillow, only for Lopez to pull it from Choo to elimiante her. Stark eliminated Lyons before being eliminated by Ruca, who went for a backflip, but Alba Fyre intercepted her with a superkick. This was followed by Fyre eliminating Ruca, bringing the final four to Jayne, Dolin, Fyre, and Valkyria. Valkyria managed to eliminate Fyre and Jade returned again, only to be sent over the top rope by Valkyria, who was also eliminated, again. Afterwards, the two brawled. In the closing moments, Dolin and Jayne punched each other, sending both to the floor at the same time. It was then announced that Dolin and Jayne co-won the match and would face Perez for the NXT Women's Championship at NXT Vengeance Day.
Afterwards, Shawn Michaels was shown at a conference table, where he announced that due to the issue with the ropes, Bron Breakker and Grayson Waller would face each other for the NXT Championship again at NXT Vengeance Day, this time in a