Investors Syndicate
Tappan believed that he could help reconcile the differences dividing the Western agricultural, logging and mining states and Wall Street, and promote financial independence for ordinary citizens. Tappan later recounted, “I conceived of the idea of a thrift plan upon a conservative honest basis, that would appeal to people as a means of investing small amounts with the safety and yield that was secured by larger investors.”.[1] His attitudes were in stark contrast to those of his wealthy New York relations, such as his second cousin, the banker Frederick D. Tappen.
In 1894, Tappan and local Minneapolis attorney Henry Farnham submitted articles of incorporation for a new firm, Investors Syndicate. After receiving approval from the state commissioner of insurance, the company was organized under the general incorporation statute of Minnesota in July 1894 with $50,000 in capital. As expressed in its charter, its purpose was extremely broad. Investors Syndicate was authorized to deal in government and corporate bonds, stocks, mortgages notes, and all kinds of personal property, to buy and sell such instruments for other persons, and to issue its own notes and obligations of debt. Tappan also conceived of a new investment certificate, which he called a “face amount certificate.” Tappan's certificates paid around 6 percent, which was several points above what banks could offer and well above the 2 percent on government bonds of 3 percent on railroad bonds. The higher yield made them attractive to investors who were looking to increase the earning power of their savings without taking the risks of corporate stocks. “Its object,” Tappan wrote, “is to encourage frugality and to assist and encourage its patrons in saving systematically small sums monthly.” [2]
In November, 1896 Tappan married Winifred Gallagher, a secretary and Irish immigrant from Tubbercurry, County Sligo. That January Tappan graduated from the University of Minnesota College of Law. Winnie typed company letters and running the office of the Investors Syndicate, and soon became an integral part of the Investors Syndicate's team. By the end of that year, Investors Syndicate had assets of $2,500 and a handful of subscribers. Tappan truly believed that he had developed a revolutionary financial product and he set out to prove it, despite several setbacks. Despite several Minnesota banks going under, the predicted upsurge in orders for face-amount certificates did not materialize. Then the company's president, George McDonald, was jailed for “swindling” after being convicted of selling bonds by making false claims. Tappan learned through the high-profile investigations of insurance companies in 1905 that investments had to be kept separate from gambling and speculation. Though the investment certificate did not have a gambling feature, in January 1897 the postmaster general of Washington State accused Investors Syndicate and Tappan of “being engaged in a lottery for the distribution of money”. Tappan scrambled to prove the validity of his investment certificates, but the company was eventually accused of fraud and lost its mailing privileges. Tappan was furious, and after various appeals to the Postmaster General and Justice Department went unanswered, Tappan and Farnham managed to successfully appeal to their congressman and have their mailing privileges restored. In September 1897, Tappan was able to satisfy the Post Office by agreeing that Investors Syndicate would be allowed to pay out all the old business on the books, but not write any new business except under a modified contract. By the end of 1899, Investors Syndicate had written over 300 contracts, done $100,000 in business, and paid out over $11,000 in returns to its early investors.[3]
In 1901, the U.S. Post Office curtailed the company's mailing privileges once again. Tappan immediately set out for Washington, D.C. He believed that the Post Office attorney was in effect extorting business out of investment companies with the help of postal inspectors. Tappan eventually left Washington with just one charge against the company, following a full investigation. Tappan had modified the method of maturity in his contracts, so that coupons of the same contact matured in different months. The investigators ruled that such a feature bordered on the “multiple” system, whereby an element of chance was added to the investment. In reality, the feature existed to make the certificates more attractive by speeding up the time when the investor saw his or her return, but the postal investigators found it to be gambling. Investors Syndicate escaped the “scandal” largely unscathed. The Minneapolis Journal reported on the story, and the successful resolution of the problem only served to reinforce their conviction that the “face amount certificate” was legitimate and legal.
Later that year Tappan filed a claim and established homestead rights in the burgeoning hamlet of Angora, forty miles north of Duluth. He and Winnie built farm buildings, planted crops and raised Angora goats, and established the township of Angora with their farmer neighbors, many of whom were new immigrants from Finland. His work on the farm showed him the clear struggles facing American farmers and their precarious financial situations.
Back in Minneapolis, Investors Syndicate began to expand outside of their personal and professional networks and expand their portfolio. This effort was curtailed when a $10,000 loan to the National Securities Company, had to be written off when the company went bankrupt. Then J.W. Earl, who since 1900 had run the agency system that marketed the “face amount certificates”, died in December 1910. The Investors Syndicate's future looked bleak. In 1913, help arrived for Tappan, in the form of John Salmon Hibbert, who took the position of General Sales Agent. Hibbert established a geographically extensive agency and built on Tappan's already prominent insurance template for sales. The syndicate began to bloom beyond expectations, and three years after Hibbert's appointment, the company had become one of the largest and most successful investment companies in Minnesota. By 1921, the company would hold over $3 million in insurance policies. In February 1914, Hibbert was elected vice president and general manager of Investors Syndicate. The company was getting so big, that by December 1914, Tappan owned less stock in Investors Syndicate than did others. Tappan only began to draw a salary from his work at Investors Syndicate in 1915. Prior to that he'd invested his salary and profits back into the firm. By 1917, Investors Syndicate had assets of nearly $1 million. Tappan's law firm was also thriving, enhanced by his nephew Thomas F. Gallagher, later a Justice of the Minnesota Supreme Court and gubernatorial candidate. In 1925, Tappan took his family on a six-month Grand Tour of Europe and the Middle East. Four months into the trip, Tappan was blindsided when his associates John Hibbert and A. W. King sent him a telegram announcing that they were selling their shares in Investors Syndicate. Tappan rushed back to Minneapolis. Even though he felt that he had been back-stabbed by his co-workers, Tappan finally decided to join them and sell the company. He later said that selling the company felt like losing a child.
