Disposals, closures and re-branding
In the past, there were numerous independent Brewers Fayre pubs without attached hotels. However, in July 2006, Whitbread made the decision to sell the 239 stand-alone Brewers Fayre and Beefeater pubs. The sale also encompassed four additional sites that had yet to begin trading. These locations historically generated lower revenues, and since their growth had stagnated in comparison to the expanding Premier Inn sites, Whitbread considered them an obstacle to the company's sales growth. The sites were subsequently sold to rival Mitchells & Butlers, and over the course of the following year, the pubs underwent rebranding, with former Beefeater sites being converted to Toby Carvery and former Brewers Fayres rebranded as Harvester, and a variety of other brands. A substantial number of sites were converted into Pubs & Carvery (later Crown Carveries), which subsequently fueled the growth of the brand, which initially comprised only a limited number of pubs across the United Kingdom. Since 2016, Crown Carveries have undergone rebranding as "Stonehouse Pizza & Carvery."
A number of stand-alone Brewers Fayre locations were kept as they featured enough land to build a Premier Inn, like The Three Bells near Lymington and The Craigside Inn in Llandudno. In July 2008, Whitbread sold 44 more Brewers Fayre & Beefeater sites to Mitchells and Butlers as they could not obtain planning permission for a Premier Inn (like The Lauriston Farm in Edinburgh). In exchange, they were sold 21 Express by Holiday Inn hotels, which were then converted into Premier Inns.
In 2023, Whitbread announced that it was looking to sell around 250 of its 400 Beefeater and Brewers Fayre sites, due to losses and poor sales. Initially, it was thought all sites might have been put up for sale. Greene King and other competitors are looking to acquire these sites.[4]
On 24 March 2024, Whitbread announced it has drafted in advisors Christie & Co to sell between 30 and 50 of its poorest-performing Beefeater and Brewers Fayre outlets to market rivals, such as Mitchells and Butlers and Greene King, most of which were situated next-door to Premier Inn hotels. Sources added a further 100 of these pubs and restaurants are expected to be converted into extra hotel rooms for Premier Inn locations.[5] 126 under-performing Beefeater, Brewers Fayre, and Table Tables will be put up for sale, leaving the brand with 196 "better-performing" branded restaurants.
The closure process began in July 2024, starting with the de-branding of Beefeater and Brewers Fayre pubs that had Premier Inns attached. These pubs were subsequently restricted to serving only hotel guests.