Reception
Blue Lightning on the Atari Jaguar CD garnered a mixed reception from critics.[42][45] Game Players' Jeff Lundrigan commended the variety of terrains, Top Gun-inspired soundtrack, and number of planes to choose from, but faulted its "blocky" bitmap visuals and repetitive gameplay, which was compared with After Burner. Lundrigan also expressed that outside of the pre-rendered cutscnenes and soundtrack "there's really nothing to distinguish this as a CD-ROM game."[39] GameFan's three reviewers highlighted its introduction sequence, missions, and garage rock-style music, but criticized the "chunky" graphics and compared it unfavorably with Air Combat (1995).[40] Next Generation also compared it with After Burner but noted its variety of selectable planes and fast action.[43]
Game Zero Magazine's two reviewers commended the cinematics but found its gameplay too linear and similar to the Lynx original. They agreed with Lundrigan, commenting "there was nothing in this game justifying CD-ROM, and nothing graphically impressive."[47] GamePro's Lawrence Neves regarded it as a mediocre title, faulting the background visuals and clunky controls. Neves also felt its gameplay was slow compared to After Burner and Starblade.[50] In contrast, VideoGames Jim Loftus found the graphics admirable though not near to Sega Saturn or PlayStation standards, the hard rock soundtrack fitting but muffled, and its playability addictive.[49] Fusions John Wesley Hardin disagreed with Loftus, stating that "it just doesn't make a good game for a CD system in 1995."[46]
Electronic Gaming Monthly's four writers echoed similar thoughts, criticizing the audiovisual presentation, slow gameplay, choppy technical performance, and controls. While the different style of aircraft were seen as an appealing addition, they recommended the original Lynx game instead.[38] Marc Abramson of the French ST Magazine commended its animated sequences and digitized sound, but ultimately found the game average.[48] MAN!ACs Robert Bannert lambasted the game's audio and visuals.[41] AllGames Kyle Knight shared a similar opinion as other reviewers, criticizing the graphical presentation for its poor use of sprite scaling and low frame rate, as well as the repetitive soundtrack, voice acting, controls, and poor gameplay.[37] Atari Gaming Headquarters' Keita Iida concurred with Knight, writing that "Blue Lightning for the JagCD is neither the hardware showcase that its portable wonder was, nor does it possess half the gameplay that Lynx BL offered."[44]
Retrospective coverage
Retrospective commentary for Blue Lightning on Jaguar CD has been equally mixed.[51] Author Andy Slaven wrote that the game "looks, sounds, and plays just like a bad 16-bit cart." Slaven also questioned Atari for choosing it as a pack-in game with the peripheral, commenting that Battlemorph would have been a better choice.[52] The Atari Times' Dan Loosen found its gameplay fun but underwhelming and the soundtrack fitting, but gave negative comments towards the visuals. Loosen also agreed with Slaven, stating that Battlemorph should have been a pack-in game with the Jaguar CD.[53] Nils of the German website neXGam gave the title a very mixed retrospective outlook.[54]